After visiting the Moped Army, I was told my best bet would be to J-B Weld the hole I created. So I went out and bought some "slow" curring J-B Weld and gave it a shot.
|I used heat shrink to fill in the screw hole trying to prevent the weld from
seeping into the hole. It ended up working really well.
|After it dried over night, we scored the weld down the middle and it cracked it open with out a fuss.
I hope it holds.